Ontario Electricity Regulation Crisis Report Part 57: Toronto Hydro’s Negligence for Thorncliffe Park Blackout

Starting at about 3pm on Friday March 8, thousands of residents and businesses in the Thorncliffe Park, one of Toronto’s most densely packed high rise neighbourhoods, suffered a blackout. Power was restored in a piecemeal fashion. Three large apartment towers were in the dark for about 33 hours.

Toronto Hydro has repeatedly suggested that aging infrastructure was responsible for the blackout. Here is Toronto Hydro Vice President, Blair Peberdy, on the CBC radio show Metro Morning March 11 repeatedly blaming the blackout on aging infrastructure and under-investment.

New information is emerging that the equipment failure that caused the blackout was relatively young in service age, that maintenance deficiencies with that specific equipment were well known to Toronto Hydro far in advance, and that Toronto Hydro allowed that specific equipment with known defects to deteriorate until the blackout occurred.

The immediate cause of the Thorncliffe Park blackout appears to have been the failure of a sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) gas switch. The particular switch in question is approximately 20 years old. The switch in question is widely used in the utility industry and is known to be safe and long-lived equipment when properly maintained. It is designed for a much longer service life than 20 years. Key to the safe operation of the switch is a secure seal around the pressurized cabinet containing the electrical equipment. A gasket seal on the cabinet door contains the SF6 gas. A pressure gauge on the cabinet measures the internal pressure. A drop in pressure indicates a leak.

Several months ago, the switch in question was reported to have a declining gas pressure indicating a leak. Rather than fix the gas leak and re-pressurize the system — a routine maintenance operation — the switch was instead left to run until failure.

About five weeks ago, this switch failed, but was relatively quickly reset and power restored.

The early leak detection followed by a small failure demonstrates negligence on behalf of Toronto Hydro in its decision to run that specific switch to failure. Negligent maintenance, not aging, caused the failure.

On March 8th the switch failed catastrophically.

Many SF6 switches on Toronto Hydro’s system are known to be leaking. Thorncliffe Park is just one of many such blackouts that will become more frequent until responsible maintenance practices are restored at Toronto Hydro.

Toronto Hydro’s practice of allowing maintenance to slide to the point of leaving customers in the dark is similar to the approach Toronto Hydro took to managing Hurricane Sandy last November. As documented previously, Toronto Hydro deliberately planned to leave customers in the dark during and after Hurricane Sandy.

Part 58 of this series will analyze the circumstances leading up to the Thorncliffe Park blackout. The analysis will include a review of the roles of Toronto Hydro’s Board of Directors and Ontario Energy Board in the blackout, and the false rate information reported by Toronto Hydro’s Vice President Mr. Peberdy on CBC’s Metro Morning March 11.

People with knowledge about the state of Toronto Hydro’s SF6 switches and the Thorncliffe Park switch in particular are invited to contact me through the response form on this web site.

 

7 Comments

  1. When I first saw that interview, I too questioned the explanation given and stated to my wife, “something isn’t right here……..I bet there’s more than meets the eye here!”
    Thanks for this revelation…………..I’m sure most Torontonians have no idea how precarious their energy supply has become with Toronto Hydro’s mismanagement and huge debts which are affecting these types of blackouts which should become more and more prevalent this year!
    Of course Mainstream News wouldn’t want this information to be made public would it?

  2. Thanks for your information. On November 19th 2012, Hydro installed an equipment infront of 27 Thorncliffe Park where the residents of that building did not have hydro nor water.

    In december a water man broke infront of 27 Thorncliffe Park and we had no hydro again. I strongly beleive the cause of the water main was due to the implementation of what hydro did on November 19th. In December 2012 we had not hydro for 10 hours, thus causing me to give a personal day for being off from work.

    January 2013 we had another black out this one lated 15 hours lost another personal day. If hydro had investigated the problem in December 2012 when the water main broke, they would have realized that the problem existed when they inserted the old swithc on top of the old one.

    This black out that happens on March 8 should not take place, I feel that hydro is neglient.

    I send in a claim to hydro for the food I lost, got an answer if the problem is hydro they will pay as they have to investigae, that came from their Insuranced Cunningham & Lindsey, will send you a copy of the letter that I have received.

  3. i received a release form today april 8th from Cunningham & Lindsey that hydro will pay me $50
    this is not enough to cover my losses

    what r other residents saying or doing about this?

  4. Pingback: Thorncliffe Park Blackout Town Hall April 13 | Tom Adams Energy - ideas for a smarter grid

  5. Pingback: Toronto Hydro seeking gag agreement at Thorncliffe Park | Tom Adams Energy - ideas for a smarter grid

  6. Pingback: Newfoundland & Labrador PUB seeks explanation for blackouts | Tom Adams Energy - ideas for a smarter grid

  7. Pingback: Toronto Hydro’s ratepayers pay dearly for electing GTA Liberals | Energy Probe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *